Pointed vs. Scalloped Bread Knives

The Best Bread Knife: Does Yours Have the Right Edge?

The Best Bread Knife: Does Yours Have the Right Edge?

Using the wrong knife can be a deal breaker for home cooks who love to create delicious, photo-worthy meals. Regardless of the recipe, a proper chef’s knife will often get you from point A to point B unscathed, which is why many home cooks invest in a good one and leave it at that. This is fine in most cases since the chef's knife really is a must in any kitchen. But there is another vital tool to keep in mind: the bread knife – given it has the right edge.

The Best Bread Knife: Pointed vs. Scalloped Edges

Ah the bread knife – that one with the long blade that everyone thinks is reserved for, you know, bread. This type of kitchen knife usually comes with saw-like points or notches along the cutting edge of the blade. This design enables the knife to slice, or really saw, through foods with tough exteriors and delicate interiors, like crusty loaves of bread, of course.

Using a bread knife usually involves exerting more force while slicing, which divides the pressure between the serrations on the blade. The number, shape and overall sharpness of the serrations also differ from bread knife to bread knife, offering two different cutting edges: pointed vs. scalloped.

The Pointed Edge Bread Knife

Serrated Bread Knife with Bread

Pointed edge bread knives, which are often simply referred to as "serrated" knives, have sharp and aggressive teeth that are designed to pierce through the hard outer crust of breads using a saw-like motion.

Using this type of knife requires exerting less force from the user, compared to straight-edged knives, but there is a downside: Those pointed serrations can create rougher cuts and produce more crumbs, especially if the blade is in need of sharpening. And if you're a bread lover, then you know you want to savor every last crumb 😜

More on Serrated Knives: The Great Steak Knife Debate: Serrated vs. Non-Serrated

The Scalloped Edge Bread Knife

Closeup of F.N. Sharp Bread Knife with bundt cake

The other type of blade edge you’re likely to encounter when searching for the best bread knife comes with scalloped or rounded serrations that are spread further apart along the cutting edge. This edge type is designed to create less crumbs while slicing through crusty loaves of bread, and can even retain flavorful juices while carving through thick-crusted roasts. 

While the scalloped bread knife may require exerting a little more force than a standard serrated knife, it's actually quite easy to use once you get the hang of it. Plus, despite the common misconception that serrated knives stay sharp longer, the scalloped serrations do a much better job of preserving that edge. Pair it with the best cutting board for your knives (like an Acacia wood one from F.N. Sharp, available in large and small) and you can spend more time breaking bread and less time cleaning up crumbs.

Are Scalloped Edges Better Than Serrated?

Closeup of F.N. Shard Bread Knife

Knowing the basic qualities of both types of bread knives will help you make an informed decision. But which knife is better for you?

In short, it comes down to how much extra time you’re willing or able to spend. Pointed edges may be effective at cutting harder items, sure. However, the mountain of crumbs left in their wake will make cleaning up after cooking more of a chore than it already is.

Premium scalloped edges, much like what you can find from a top tier manufacturer like F.N. Sharp, are best for making consistent cuts. The rounded edge creates a cleaner cut that will save you time on cleanup, while giving an aesthetic appeal to whatever you put it up against.

Can Bread Knives be Sharpened?

F.N. Sharp Bread Knife on Spine on Wooden Surface

Nothing good lasts forever, and like all knives, serrated and scalloped edges will also wear down and dull over time. Not to fret though, it is in fact possible to restore your bread knife back to working condition.

However, sharpening a bread knife is trickier than sharpening a straight-edged chef’s knife. The serrated edges are usually only sharpened on one side and must be sharpened at the specific angle specified by the brand, making it a lot more difficult for a home cooking enthusiast to navigate.

Destroying your new knife because you don’t have the necessary skills to properly sharpen it is not very cost effective – and throwing away knives is both scary and wasteful. Your best bet for maintaining the cutting edge of your bread knife is to first invest in a quality bread knife, then leave the sharpening process to the professionals.

Knife Knowledge 101: How to Sharpen Kitchen Knives

Is a Bread Knife Necessary?

Woman slicing bread with F.N. Sharp Bread Knife

While you may not use a bread knife as often as the other knives in your set, it’s still a valuable tool to add to your collection. There are countless recipes, snacks and sandwich platters that call for the use of many different types of bread. And although a chef’s knife may work well enough, it falls noticeably short when slicing through crusty loaves and other foods that require a serrated knife.

The best part of purchasing a new bread knife? It isn’t just for bread! In fact, there are tons of uses for a bread knife, from slicing through tough fruits and veggies to leveling cakes. Some quality bread knives, like what you can buy from F.N. Sharp, are designed as a cross between a bread knife and a carving knife. The scalloped edge on these beauties will not only cleanly slice through any loaf of bread, but will also retain every flavorful drop of juice when slicing standing rib roast.

Get All of the F.N. Sharp Essentials: The 6-Knife Set & Magnetic Knife Block

Check out the video below to see the F.N. Sharp Bread Knife in action:

Break Bread With These F.N. Sharp Recipes

Now that you know what makes a great edge, break out that bread knife and break some bread with these delicious recipes!

Tomato Rose Antipasto Crostinis Topped With Balsamic Vinegar Reduction

Recipe for Tomato Rose Antipasto Crostinis Topped With Balsamic Vinegar Reduction

Oh Ma, Ma, Italian food is the best! And any mama will love this pretty antipasto recipe!

This recipe involves slicing a baguette loaf and topping them with prosciutto, fontina cheese, basil leaves, vine tomatoes, and reduced balsamic vinegar to create an antipasto finger food that's easier to create than it looks! 

Cherry, Spinach and Thyme Stuffed Pork Tenderloin

Cherry, Spinach and Thyme Stuffed Pork Tenderloin Recipe

Stuff some bellies with some stuffed pork tenderloinDiced yellow onion, chopped baby spinach, diced cherries, chopped fresh thyme, and Italian seasoning all come together in this delicious recipe!

Be sure to grab a chef’s knife, a utility knife and that bread knife for prepping and slicing this beautiful labor of love 💝

Cheddar, Potato, Bacon, and Cabbage Hand Pies

Cheddar, Potato, Bacon, and Cabbage Hand Pies Recipe

Grab some puff pastry and level up your on-the-go meal game with this recipe for deliciously flaky hand pies filled with cheddar, potato, bacon and cabbage! 

As an added bonus, you can make the filling ahead of time so you can easily pull off this recipe before the gang comes over for Sunday brunch, to celebrate a big game or to celebrate a day that ends in “y.”

Oven-Roasted Corned Beef & Cabbage With French Carrot Salad & Fondant Potatoes

Recipe for Oven-Roasted Corned Beef & Cabbage With French Carrot Salad & Fondant Potatoes

Transport your taste buds to Ireland with this follow-along video recipe for oven-roasted corned beef and cabbage

This delicious take on the Irish classic serves art on a plate with perfectly seasoned, cooked and sliced corned beef, oven-roasted cabbage steaks, creamy French carrot salad and fondant potatoes!

Herby Parmesan & Veggie-Topped Focaccia Bread

Herby Parmesan & Veggie-Topped Focaccia Bread Recipe

We say focaccia, you say yum! This homemade focaccia bread is loaded with fresh and dried herbs, then topped with sweet sundried tomatoes, flavorful red onions, briny olives, and salty parmesan. Enjoy it as an appetizer, with pasta and red sauce, dipped into a creamy potato soup, served alongside a cheese platter or big steakhouse salad. The possibilities are endless!

Chocolate Marble Swirl Banana Bread

Chocolate Marble Swirl Banana Bread Recipe

Can you think about banana bread without saying “mmm”? Neither can we! And that is especially the case when you add the chocolate swirl in this recipe for marble banana bread!

The best part is you can enjoy it as is or toasted with some butter or cream cheese, or even used as a base for French toast slathered in maple syrup – oh, my, yum!

Poached Pear Gingerbread With Lemon-Ginger Syrup

Poached Pear Gingerbread With Lemon-Ginger Syrup Recipe

Get whimsical with this poached pear gingerbread recipe!

Bosc pears, dry vermouth, sugar, lemon juice, honey, ginger, cardamom, cinnamon, anise, coriander, butter, molasses, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla, flour, baking powder, baking soda and Greek yogurt and vanilla extract all come together in this deliciously sweet recipe!

Quality vs. Junk A Guide to Buying Kitchen Knives